Monday, March 16, 2009

OnlineSpin: Social Nervous System -- Or Nervous Social System?

Last week Kendall wrote "The Love/Hate Livelihood Of The Blogosphere."

Richard Monihan wrote in response, "Blogs, unfortunately, are taking the place of a variety of things. Among them: The newspaper, the radio, the magazine, the political pundits, The self-help/DIY crowd.

I say unfortunately because there USED to be a way to get your creds by becoming a writer for a major outlet. You had to prove yourself somehow.

Of course, several years ago this began to change and TV began the development of the 'do nothing/know nothing' commentator du jour.

So blogs are really just an extension of this pop culture twist.

This isn't to say all blogs are worthless.

But most do simply perpetuate useless memes.

They are rarely fact-checked, they are usually just opinion-based, many engage pop culture references that lack value, many employ urban myths and legends as fact.

Blogs, in the broadest sense, are the ultimate 'dumbing down' of information.

HOWEVER, they are also the greatest democratizing vehicle for information in history. Now everyone has 'a voice.'

And some blogs really are quite good.

Finding your way through the brush is quite difficult, though.

I am left to ponder if the TV show 'Max Headroom' wasn't far off. If you substitute the internet and blogs for the democratic/auctionable TV market from that show, you have the current situation we are in today.

Lots of voices, all competing for eyeballs, and rapid rating jumps as tastes shift from moment to moment. "

Monday, March 16, 2009
Social Nervous System -- Or Nervous Social System?
By Kendall Allen

Last week, I was captivated by three flashes of content that sparked the media sphere: Jon Stewart going at it with Jim Cramer, stirring public commentary; Tim Armstrong taking the CEO seat at AOL, bringing on knowing banter in media circles; and a particularly well-put piece by Joshua-Michele Ross on, "The Rise of the Social Nervous System." It was an engaging and interconnected week, with the meme once again buzzing across the board. Ross' article, on what he calls the "hive mind," really hit the mark during a very buzzing week.

What is the Hive Mind?

The intense, rising interconnectivity powered by the Internet and the aggressive adoption of social media tools have spurred the social nervous system Ross describes, where we all participate in what he dubs the hive mind. "In a social nervous system there will be increasing pressure to be connected 24/7 to the hive mind that is Facebook, Twitter and so on. Those who do not connect, share and collaborate will have a hard time in business and in social life," he writes. And because communication is the base function of the Internet, when you scale up communications, you change the world.

I agree on many levels. But I can't help but wonder: is this a social nervous system or nervous social system? Nervous seems the operative word. When you look at habits, trends, character types and themes -- the palpable urgency is fascinating. Like many of you, I have been involved with digital since the early' 90s. We have watched new usage behavior emerge along with media platform and utility innovation. Research, communication, workflow management, online collaboration, and community have all seemed obsessive at one time or another. And each behavioral development moved us forward -- or moved us someplace.

Flash-forward to 2009, with social media at its compulsive hilt, and there are new, more hyper-active behaviors to consider. Within the so-called hive mind, it is the power users who are the most interesting, because they use the media with the most urgency.

The M.O. of the Power User 

I think about my friend Collins, who lives in Sidney, Australia. We reconnected recently and have discovered a number of shared networks. I have realized he is always on. I am served the articles he reads; videos he views; shows he watches; comments overheard;  random thoughts; conversation bits with people of interest; conference sound bytes; geo-political snippets. What makes this really interesting is that he was always quite shy, and he works not in media, but biochemical research. Yet he covers a full spectrum with his rapid-fire, meaty posts, tweets, diggs and social networking outreach. His recent topics (many of them from just this weekend):


  • The state of cancer research
  • Headlines in The Onion
  • Social media and consumer brand advocacy
  • Aspirations for doctor peer groups online
  • Deconstruction of the Stewart/Cramer interview
  • Elves in Iceland
  • Favored Twitter commands
  • The insecurity of Chinese leadership over U.S. debt
  • Falsity of cable programming
  • Ethics of journalism
  • His Twitter stats

    He is as well versed in the conventions of social media as anyone we know. When I look at the themes and spread someone like Collins has planted out there in the sphere, with his the round-the-clock output, I ponder these ideas:


  • How much of this is about being there, not missing a single connection point?


  • As we establish digital identity through posting, sharing, connecting, we are forcefully telegraphing value and passing cultural currency.


  • Collins didn't always have these tools, but he's always been brilliant and a great 1:1 conversationalist. Does his brain really work this way? Or, is this a sort of curated consciousness?

    Social Media is a Talkie Media

    In our day-to day-life, the adage that actions speak louder than words has always rung true. We respect those who show us instead of tell us. The show creates our perception of their personality. Yet, in the digital media sphere, where social media drives connectivity -- words, links, packets of information allow us to literally curate our public perception. We derive our identity there from the tell.

    Ross also says "the outcome of the social nervous system is that we see the shift away from privacy as an inalienable right to an individual responsibility." This rings true. If you have written, been written about, been hired or fired, posted photos, or networked online -- you have at least a seed of a digital identity. And, if you don't take hold of it, it will take on a life of its own. I have always believed this.

    Certainly, those of us who are in the business, along with avid media consumers (and Collins), take this to the extreme. We are managing digital identities and establishing our footprint all day long. We have a new relationship with our own privacy. And aggressive, agile use of social networking tools, micro-blogging in particular, removes additional boundaries. As dexterous digital natives, it's not clear that we care.

    I do not know what the future holds. Will there come a time, with new behaviors coming to the fore, that we dial back the digital identities established today? Will we erase our footprints and move on to another place? Is that even possible?

    During the most colorful, buzzing weeks in media, I think about conversations with my dad. He was a newsman with Knight Ridder for 35 or so years, and we talk often on the future of journalism, media and related ethics or community issues. Since the early days of the Internet, we've had great talks on online media and digital platforms. But we quietly draw the line at topics like heavy-duty social media. If I were to even speak of digital identity and one's personal brand, he would smile and tell me he knows exactly who I am. And then we'd start picking apart the Stewart/Cramer smackdown.




  • Kendall Allen is headquartered in New York City. She consults for publishers and agencies on integrating digital -- most recently at MKTG, where she just completed a long-term assignment. Previously she was managing director of Incognito Digital, LLC, an independent digital media agency and creative studio. She also held top posts at iCrossing and Fathom Online.

    Online Spin for Monday, March 16, 2009:

    You are receiving this newsletter at as part of your free membership with MediaPost. If this issue was forwarded to you and you would like to begin receiving a copy of your own, please visit our site - - and click on [subscribe] in the e-newsletter box.
    For advertising opportunities see our online media kit.

    If you'd rather not receive this newsletter in the future click here.
    email powered by eROIWe welcome and appreciate forwarding of our newsletters in their entirety or in part with proper attribution.
    (c) 2009 MediaPost Communications, 1140 Broadway, 4th Floor, New York, NY 10001

    No comments:

    Blog Archive